The Art of Empathic Confrontation: Communicating with a Narcissistic Co-Parent

If you’re co-parenting with a narcissistic ex, you know how disorienting, frustrating, and emotionally draining every exchange can be. You’re caught in a pattern where their coping strategies—like blaming, gaslighting, or playing the victim—make it nearly impossible to have a productive conversation.

But there is a way to confront the behavior without escalating the conflict. It’s called empathic confrontation—a powerful schema therapy technique that blends honesty with compassion. And when used well, it can be a game-changer for navigating close relationships with high-conflict or personality disorder traits, like narcissism.

Empathic Confrontation: What It Is and Why It Works

Empathic confrontation is a technique used in schema therapy, an integrative psychotherapy approach developed by Jeffrey Young. It helps clients identify and shift early maladaptive schemas—deep, often unconscious beliefs like “I’m unlovable” or “People always leave me.” These maladaptive beliefs often show up in toxic co-parenting dynamics as controlling behavior, emotional withdrawal, or chronic external conflicts.

Unlike aggressive or punitive confrontation, empathic confrontation allows you to acknowledge the pain or unmet needs driving the behavior—without excusing it. The goal is to highlight the discrepancy between someone’s current actions and their deeper emotional needs, while preserving the therapeutic alliance or, in co-parenting terms, the ability to keep communication functioning.

Schema Therapy and Co-Parenting with a Narcissist

Schema therapy is particularly effective when dealing with personality disorders, including narcissistic traits. In these cases, your co-parent may be stuck in overcompensating modes or coping mode behaviors that developed to protect them from early emotional wounds. While you can’t reparent your ex, you can learn techniques to help clients identify these patterns—and in your case, to recognize them so you don’t take the bait.

When a narcissistic co-parent lashes out, they may be protecting themselves from an underlying emotional trigger, such as shame or a fear of abandonment. With empathic confrontation, you can respond in a way that’s firm, yet non-threatening, enabling lasting change in the tone of your communication—even if the other person doesn’t change.

Empathic Confrontation in Schema Therapy

In clinical practice, empathic confrontation in schema therapy is used to help the client stuck in destructive loops understand how their self-defeating behavior keeps their core needs unmet. Therapists use tools like imagery rescripting, dialogue, and limited reparenting to guide clients toward adaptive behaviors.

Get the BestInterest App for Coparents:
Scan the QR code to download for your device, or tap to download:

But even outside therapy, you can use elements of this approach:

• Empathically acknowledge the need (e.g., “It seems like you’re feeling unheard or dismissed.”)
• Confront the behavior (e.g., “Still, using threats isn’t going to help us resolve this.”)
• Set a limit that protects you and your child (e.g., “I’m happy to talk when we can both stay focused on the kids.”)

These strategies are used in both individual and group schema therapy contexts, and now, increasingly, in co-parenting coaching and family conflict resolution.

Why Schema Work Matters in High-Conflict Parenting

Wendy Behary, author of Disarming the Narcissist and a global leader in schema therapy, describes empathic confrontation as essential when dealing with narcissists. Behary is known for teaching techniques to help clients break free from the trap of either collapsing into submission or escalating the fight.

“Empathic confrontation doesn’t mean giving in,” says Behary. “It means standing firm while still respecting the human behind the behavior.”

Listen to Wendy’s podcast on expert strategies on disarming the narcissist

Her art of empathic confrontation has become a cornerstone of training and supervision through the International Society of Schema Therapy (ISST), helping therapists and clients around the world handle maladaptive coping modes with clarity and empathy.

Limited Reparenting for Yourself

While limited reparenting is typically used by therapists to help the client feel emotionally safe enough to heal, you can apply its principles to yourself. That means soothing your own inner child, validating your own feelings, and setting protective boundaries instead of endlessly trying to please or placate your ex.

This inner work is critical when dealing with maladaptive behavior. If your ex is stuck in maladaptive schemas, it’s not your job to fix them—but it is your responsibility to not get pulled into their emotional storms.

Coping with the Fallout: Strategies for Emotional Safety

When you use empathic confrontation, it doesn’t always mean the other person will respond kindly. That’s why your coping system matters. Here’s how to support yourself:

• Practice self-compassion and remind yourself that you’re doing the best you can.
• Use the BestInterest app to draft, review, and even AI-filter your responses before sending them.
• Work with a coach trained in schema therapy or narcissistic communication.
• Reflect on your schema triggers—are you reacting from your healthy adult self, or from a wounded place?

These aren’t just nice-to-haves—they’re essential for emotional survival when co-parenting with a narcissist.

You Can Communicate with Strength and Compassion

Empathic confrontation is not about fixing your narcissistic ex. It’s about helping them identify patterns (if they’re willing) and most importantly, helping you respond from a place of calm, power, and empathy.

By learning to use empathic confrontation, you give yourself a powerful tool for staying grounded in chaotic situations. You don’t abandon yourself. You don’t escalate the conflict. You stand in truth and compassion—and that’s where real resolution begins.

If you’re ready to apply this in your day-to-day co-parenting, the BestInterest app and Coparent Coach feature can help you start practicing this technique today.

Ready for less conflict? The BestInterest coparent app is endorsed by family law experts and trusted by coparents just like you.

Share this article: