Understanding Dog Whistling in Coparenting: Addressing Subtle Manipulation

In the world of coparenting, challenges can arise in many forms. Some are overt and easy to identify, while others are more subtle, insidious, and harder to address. One such tactic is dog whistling—a form of covert communication designed to send a specific message or provoke a reaction while appearing harmless or neutral on the surface.

If you’re dealing with dog whistling in your coparenting relationship, understanding it is the first step toward addressing its impact.

What is Dog Whistling in Coparenting?

Dog whistling refers to subtle, coded communication where a coparent uses seemingly innocuous comments, behaviors, or actions to convey a hidden message or provoke an emotional reaction. To outsiders, these remarks may appear innocent or even kind, but to the intended target, they carry a clear and often harmful subtext.

Examples in coparenting might include:

• A parent consistently emphasizing how “the kids were so much calmer” at their house, implying the other parent creates chaos.
• Remarks like, “Oh, they didn’t have time to finish their homework. Maybe it’s because they’re too tired after staying with you,” subtly suggesting the other parent is neglectful.
• Bringing up past conflicts in a veiled manner, such as, “I know how much you care about routines now,” which hints at past disagreements or perceived failings.

Ready for less conflict? The BestInterest coparent app is endorsed by family law experts and trusted by coparents just like you.

Why is Dog Whistling Harmful?

While the words themselves may seem harmless, the hidden intent behind dog whistling can cause:

• Emotional Distress: The subtle jabs or insinuations can leave the targeted parent feeling invalidated, attacked, or frustrated.
• Self-Doubt: Over time, constant veiled criticism may erode confidence in one’s parenting abilities.
• Conflict Escalation: Even if the targeted parent reacts calmly, repeated dog whistles can create tension that spills over into other aspects of the coparenting relationship.
• Child Impact: If children pick up on tension or are directly involved in dog whistling scenarios, it can affect their sense of security and well-being.

How Dog Whistling Feels

Experiencing dog whistling from your coparent often feels like:

• Gaslighting: You might question whether you’re overreacting because the remarks seem minor or innocent to others. Friends and family may downplay your experience and even call you “crazy”.
• Walking on Eggshells: You may feel a constant need to defend yourself or anticipate hidden messages in every interaction. You may attempt to distance yourself or avoid situations where the other parent will be present.
• Isolation: Without others recognizing the subtext, you might feel unsupported or misunderstood when seeking help.
• Anger or Frustration: The subtle nature of dog whistling can leave you feeling angry, yet unsure how to respond without escalating the situation.

Why Do Manipulative Coparents Use Dog Whistling?

Dog whistling isn’t just about veiled criticism; it’s often a deliberate strategy that relies on plausible deniability. This means the person delivering the message can claim innocence, making it harder for others to see their actions as manipulative or harmful. It’s a particularly insidious form of emotional abuse.

Here’s why plausible deniability is such an effective tool of abuse:

1. Deflection of Responsibility
   The manipulative coparent can deny the true intent of their words, saying things like, “You’re overreacting,” or, “That’s not what I meant.” This shifts the focus from their behavior to your reaction, leaving you feeling invalidated or self-conscious.
2. Erosion of Confidence
   Because the manipulation is subtle, it can make you second-guess your feelings or perceptions. Over time, this can chip away at your confidence, especially if you feel unsupported in identifying or addressing the behavior.
3. Creating a “Good Parent” Image
   To outsiders, the manipulative person may appear reasonable or even caring. This façade helps them maintain their reputation while subtly undermining you. For example, they might say something like, “I know how hard it is for you to get the kids to school on time,” framing it as a helpful comment while subtly insinuating you’re disorganized.
4. Provoking Emotional Reactions
   The ambiguity of dog whistling can make it especially frustrating. If you react emotionally, the manipulative person can use your reaction against you, portraying you as irrational or overly sensitive.

How to Address Plausible Deniability

• Stick to the Facts: When responding, focus on concrete actions or specific language, rather than assumptions about intent. For example, say, “I noticed you mentioned the kids’ homework wasn’t finished.” BIFF or JADE can be good tools to employ here.
• Limit Emotional Engagement: Avoid reacting emotionally to subtle provocations. Staying calm denies the manipulative person the response they’re seeking.
• Use a Communication Platform: Apps like BestInterest ensure interactions are documented and help filter communication, which makes it harder for a manipulative coparent to hide behind vague or undermining comments.
• Seek Validation: Talk to a trusted friend, therapist, or support group about your experiences. Outside perspectives can help you feel more confident in recognizing and addressing dog whistling.

Understanding how plausible deniability plays into dog whistling is a key step in managing these behaviors. By refusing to engage in the manipulative dynamic, you can protect your emotional well-being and create a healthier environment for yourself and your children.

Name-Dropping as a Dog Whistle

When used manipulatively, name dropping often involves subtle or vague mentions of interactions with mutual acquaintances, family members, or others close to your shared world. Here is what name-dropping does:

1. Creating Uncertainty
   • The manipulative coparent might mention a conversation with someone you both know but remain vague about the details. For example, “I was talking to your mom the other day. She had some thoughts about how the kids are doing lately.”
   • This kind of statement is designed to make you question what was said and possibly doubt how others perceive you, leading to feelings of anxiety or insecurity.
2. Implying Judgment
   • Name-dropping can subtly imply that others are critical of you or your parenting, even if the specifics are never stated. For example, “Your sister was asking if the kids have been eating well. I wasn’t sure what to say.”
   • This can feel like an attack on your abilities as a parent, couched in plausible deniability since the manipulator can claim they were just sharing a casual comment.
3. Undermining Relationships
   • By mentioning vague or ambiguous interactions with people you trust, the manipulative coparent might aim to sow seeds of doubt or mistrust in those relationships. For instance, “Your best friend and I had an interesting chat about the custody schedule.”
   • This creates a wedge, making you wonder if others are taking sides or speaking about you behind your back.
4. Asserting Control or Superiority
   • Name-dropping can also serve to establish dominance or control, as if they have the upper hand in social or familial dynamics. For example, “I ran into your boss at the store. Small world, huh?”
   • Even if nothing malicious occurred, the ambiguity creates discomfort and reinforces their presence in aspects of your life beyond the parenting relationship.

How to Address Name-Dropping as a Manipulative Tactic

• Ask for Clarity: When they name-drop, calmly and directly ask for specifics. For example, “What exactly did my sister say again?” This approach makes it harder for them to hide behind vagueness.
• Stay Grounded: Remind yourself that the manipulator’s goal is often to provoke doubt or insecurity. If their claims seem suspect, consider verifying them with the third party involved, but only if it feels appropriate. Oftentimes, just ignoring the name-drop whistle can be the best approach.
• Document the Interaction: Keeping a written record of these types of statements can help you identify patterns of manipulation over time and respond more effectively.
• Focus on Your Relationships: If their comments are designed to undermine your trust in others, focus on strengthening those relationships. Direct communication with family or friends can prevent misinterpretation and clarify intentions.
• Avoid Overreacting: Responding calmly denies the manipulator the reaction they’re seeking. For example, “It’s good to know you had that conversation. I’ll check in with them myself if needed.”

By recognizing name-dropping as another tool of manipulation, you can better protect your emotional well-being and maintain healthy boundaries. This awareness is a crucial step in fostering a more positive coparenting dynamic or, at the very least, reducing the manipulative impact on your life.

Strategies for Coping with Dog Whistling

The experience of being the victim of dog whistling can be extremely painful. Here are some strategies for coping with this otherwise challenging form of emotional abuse:

1. Identify and Acknowledge It
   Recognizing dog whistling for what it is can empower you. Reflect on patterns in your coparent’s comments or actions and their underlying messages. Naming the tactic—internally or with a trusted confidant—helps reduce its emotional power and allows you to observe it more objectively.
2. Document Interactions
   Keep a record of comments, emails, or messages where dog whistling occurs. This documentation may be useful if patterns emerge and you need to discuss concerns with a therapist, mediator, or attorney. Many states have coercive control laws which protect coparents from emotional abuse.
3. Set Boundaries
   Respond to dog whistling with clear, firm boundaries. For example, if your coparent insinuates something negative, calmly redirect the conversation to focus on the child’s needs. Avoid engaging in defensive arguments.
4. Focus on Emotional Regulation
   Dog whistling is designed to provoke a reaction. Practice emotional regulation techniques like deep breathing, mindfulness, or grounding exercises to stay calm and composed in the moment. The less reactive you get, the less the emotionally abusive person is likely to continue.
5. Seek Professional Support
   Therapists, coparenting coaches, or mediators can help you develop strategies to address dog whistling and maintain healthier communication dynamics. They can also provide validation and tools to navigate emotionally charged situations.
6. Leverage Communication Tools
   Coparenting apps like BestInterest offer structured communication platforms where messages are filtered for tone and appropriateness. This can minimize opportunities for dog whistling and ensure interactions remain focused on the child.
7. Prioritize the Children’s Needs
   Remember, dog whistling can create a toxic environment that may affect your children. Keeping the focus on their well-being can help you rise above manipulative tactics and reinforce your role as a steady, loving parent. Children are unlikely to understand or see this form of abuse, so don’t expect them to understand it either.

Conclusion

Dog whistling in coparenting is a subtle but impactful form of manipulation that can leave parents feeling drained, confused, and isolated. By understanding these tactics of controlling coparents, recognizing the effects, and implementing strategies to address it, you can protect your emotional well-being and maintain a healthy environment for your children.

You’re not alone in this journey. Support from professionals, friends, and tools like structured communication apps can make a significant difference in helping you navigate these challenges with confidence and resilience.

Get the FREE AI-Powered Coparenting App:

Share this article: